This article is part of our Study Skills & Academic Writing resource section
Various scholarly essays on crime and punishment have been written in the past. These works range from Fyodor Dostoevsky’s critique of utilitarianism to Sigmund Freud’s writings on justice and the human psyche. There are also essays examining the Michael Vick experience, racial disparities in criminal justice, and the role of prisons in society.
Writing a scholarly essay on these subjects requires a clear argument, relevant evidence, and a logical structure. For general guidance on organizing ideas and developing a well-supported argument, see how to write the best essay.
Table of Contents
Race, Punishment, and the Michael Vick Experience
Whether or not you like Michael Vick, it is impossible to ignore the debate about racial disparities in the criminal justice system. The original discussion cites figures from 2013, when more than 1.5 million people were incarcerated, and states that more than 60 percent were people of color. It also compares these figures with a claim about Black applicants for employment without a criminal record.
While there is no single explanation for these disparities, several factors may contribute, including harsh policies, selective policing, and limited opportunities for re-entry into society.
In Vick’s case, the NFL’s action against him was not necessarily overtly racist, although it has been interpreted as reflecting a more subtle form of racial bias. Some critics have also argued that his sentence was too lenient.
According to a study by UT Dallas criminologists, addressing race-based problems is an important step toward combating racism. The study reportedly found that African Americans perceived greater injustice in the criminal justice system than white people.
When developing an academic discussion of race and punishment, it is important to distinguish between statistical evidence, interpretations, and personal opinions. Each claim should be supported by credible sources, and the argument should acknowledge the complexity of the issue.
Dostoevsky’s Critique of Utilitarianism
Several scholarly essays on crime and punishment discuss Fyodor Dostoevsky’s critique of utilitarianism. His novel, Crime and Punishment, challenges Western European utilitarian ideas. Through the story, Dostoevsky uses his theories and views on progress to illustrate how distorted interpretations of utilitarian philosophy can produce harmful conclusions.
In Dostoevsky’s novel, Raskolnikov, the main character, suffers from a distorted interpretation of utilitarian ideology. He is a 23-year-old Russian student influenced by competing ideas associated with socialism, Darwinism, and utilitarianism.
Dostoevsky’s critique exposes what he sees as the hypocrisy of an ethical system that can justify harmful actions in the name of practical outcomes. The novel shows how a supposedly rational attitude can lead to individual suffering and wider social harm.
Dostoevsky is not merely a novelist but also a thinker who challenges Western European utilitarian philosophies. He explores how a practical mindset can encourage a false sense of superiority and how a rigid, purely functional perspective may have unintended consequences.
When writing about a literary work, define important philosophical terms and explain how they relate to the characters and themes. A useful starting point is to understand the difference between describing a concept and analyzing it. The guide to writing a definition essay offers further ideas for explaining concepts clearly and supporting them with examples.
Sigmund Freud’s Essays on Crime and Punishment
Sigmund Freud’s essays on crime and punishment explore the human psyche and its relationship to society. His analysis extends beyond crime itself to questions about human motivation, psychological conflict, and social behavior. As a result, his ideas have generated considerable discussion and controversy.
A key aspect of Freud’s work was his development of psychoanalytic theory. Throughout his career, he published numerous volumes of theoretical work, and his ideas and clinical studies became influential in psychology.
For instance, Freud proposed that the mind used various defense mechanisms and explored the significance of dreams. He also described the superego as a powerful source of internal demands and moral judgment. His ideas developed over time, and he was capable of revising his views in response to new thinking and observations.
Freud wrote about repression, which he considered a normal psychological process that could operate differently in neurotic illness. He also argued that repressed drives could be transformed or redirected.
During his time in Vienna, Freud studied under Ernst Brücke. Brücke’s lectures on physiology influenced Freud’s early thinking, and Freud adopted ideas associated with dynamic physiology.
When discussing Freud’s theories, a strong scholarly essay should explain the relevant concepts, connect them to the subject of crime and punishment, and distinguish historical theories from current interpretations. Careful research and a clear outline can help keep complex discussions organized.
Prisons Have Vacillated Between Punitive and Therapeutic Approaches to Inmates
Whether for rehabilitation or deterrence, prisons have vacillated between punitive and therapeutic approaches to inmates. In the 19th century, new legal policies and administrative practices were applied vigorously. Yet, despite their widespread use, many people questioned whether these approaches were practical. The original article also references this discussion through an external resource on the advantages of buying an argumentative essay for sale.
A large number of incarcerated people have serious mental health needs. The article cites a study reporting that more than half of all state prisoners had a history of untreated mental illness. The New York City jail system developed a treatment unit offering therapy and other activities for people with serious mental illnesses. However, such units can be more expensive than earlier approaches and may require additional healthcare staff, making them difficult to administer.
Another way prisons punish inmates is through solitary confinement. People held in a separate confinement unit may be isolated for 22–24 hours a day. This can be particularly harmful for juvenile offenders. The original article also notes that internal CHS reviews found disproportionate levels of violence associated with solitary confinement.
These examples illustrate the tension between punishment, deterrence, rehabilitation, and humane treatment. A scholarly essay should examine the evidence for each approach and explain how prison policies affect individuals and society.
Developing a Strong Scholarly Essay
A scholarly essay on crime and punishment should have a focused thesis, organized supporting arguments, and a conclusion that follows from the evidence. Begin by identifying the question you want to answer, then organize your research into sections that develop different aspects of the argument.
An outline is especially useful when comparing several perspectives, such as racial disparities, philosophical arguments, psychological theories, and prison policy. For practical advice on structuring a technology-focused essay, see how to develop an outline for writing an essay about technology. Although the subject differs, the same outlining principles can help organize complex research topics.
Pay attention to your essay’s title as well. A specific title can communicate the focus of your argument and help readers understand what the discussion will cover. If you are preparing work for an academic competition, this guide on how to select the best title for your essay-writing competition offers additional guidance.
Technology can also affect how students research, draft, and revise academic work. Digital tools may help with organizing sources and improving clarity, but any information they provide should be checked for accuracy. Learn more about how technology is transforming assignment writing in education.
Finally, scholarly writing needs careful attention to evidence, wording, and structure. Review each paragraph to ensure it contributes to your argument, and revise unclear sentences or unsupported claims. For more guidance on the importance of planning and reviewing essays, read why essay writing needs lots of attention.
Strong academic writing improves through practice, feedback, and revision. You can find further practical tips in this guide on how to step up your writing game.
